I’ve always been told to be careful what I wish for, but I’ve never been particularly good at following that advice. Take the time I wished everyone would just leave me alone for an entire day: No phone calls, no text messages and absolutely nobody interrupting me while I was trying to relax.
Sounds like paradise, right? Well, apparently the universe has a sense of humor, because the next day my phone stopped working, the internet went out and I discovered that being disconnected from civilization is considerably less enjoyable when you can’t even watch Netflix. Suddenly, I was wishing someone would call me, if only to give me something to complain about.
Of course, that’s the problem with wishes. We spend so much time thinking about what we want that we rarely consider the consequences of actually getting them. Wishing for $1 million sounds wonderful until you discover it came from a life insurance policy. Wishing to lose 20 pounds seems reasonable until someone hands you a hacksaw. Horror movies have exploited that particular loophole for decades, and if the Wishmaster franchise taught us anything, it’s that supernatural beings offering to grant your deepest desires probably aren’t doing it out of the goodness of their hearts.
Directed by Chris LaMartina, Spirit Tasting follows three former punk-rock bandmates, Will (Sean Doherty), Sailor (Melissa LaMartina) and Jake (Trevor Wilhelms), as they reunite on New Year’s Eve at the Red Bat Distillery to remember their deceased friend and fellow musician, Robbie (Philip Doccolo). Their evening of drinking and reminiscing takes an unusual turn when they encounter Solomon (Matt Lake), an eccentric, self-important sommelier who invites them to an exclusive tasting of various liquors and spirits.
The tasting comes with one peculiar requirement: With every new bottle, each participant must make a wish. Some are relatively harmless, while others reveal deeper regrets and personal frustrations.
Joining them are bartender Grace (Tatiana Nya Ford) and married couple Hannah (Cate Paris) and Fisher (Matt Baughman), whose troubled relationship adds another layer of tension. Initially, the exercise seems like an unusual drinking game hosted by someone who takes himself far too seriously.
However, the guests soon discover that Solomon has a particular way of granting wishes, and getting exactly what you ask for might be considerably worse than getting nothing at all.

An unusual liquor tasting takes a sinister turn in Spirit Tasting.
There’s something inherently entertaining about wishes coming true in the worst possible ways. Spirit Tasting takes that familiar horror concept and wraps it around an evening of drinking with friends. Part of the fun comes from wondering how badly things might go wrong. You know there’s a catch somewhere, but figuring out exactly what that catch might be becomes part of the entertainment.
It’s a simple premise with plenty of potential for creative and gruesome consequences.
Much of that entertainment comes courtesy of Solomon, arguably the most interesting character in the film. There’s an almost comical arrogance to the way he carries himself, acting as though everyone entering his tasting room should feel fortunate just to be in his presence. He’s smug, condescending and clearly convinced he’s better than everyone around him. Even more entertaining is the pleasure he takes in his guests’ misfortune.
In his mind, he’s simply granting their wishes. If the results happen to be horrifying, perhaps they should have been more careful about what they asked for. His combination of sophistication and sadistic amusement makes him an enjoyable villain, even if I’d probably decline an invitation to sample anything he was serving.
Another area where Spirit Tasting shines is its practical effects. When things finally go wrong, the filmmakers aren’t afraid to get their hands dirty, quite literally. There’s an impressive amount of blood and genuinely convincing gore that should satisfy fans of old-school horror. The film embraces the messy, wonderfully disgusting side of the genre, delivering several memorable moments of gruesome carnage.
Some of the violence is so ridiculously excessive that it becomes funny, but that only adds to the film’s twisted charm.
What’s even more impressive is that Spirit Tasting was filmed in just four days on a budget of $40,000. LaMartina took inspiration from legendary filmmaker Roger Corman, who famously completed The Little Shop of Horrors in two days and A Bucket of Blood in five. The production even took place over LaMartina’s 40th birthday. Considering those limitations, the convincing practical effects and sheer amount of carnage are remarkable achievements. It’s a testament to what passionate independent filmmakers can accomplish with limited resources and a willingness to get creative.
Unfortunately, Spirit Tasting takes its sweet time getting to anything particularly interesting.
I’m all for a good slow burn, especially when a movie uses that time to build tension or make me care about the characters. For roughly the first 40 minutes, we’re treated to conversations, personality clashes and uncomfortable interactions that don’t do much to move the story forward. I kept waiting for something sinister to happen, but the movie seemed content to let everyone sit around drinking and arguing.
At one point, I wondered whether I’d accidentally signed up for an actual liquor tasting instead of a horror movie. At least at a real tasting, I’d have something to drink while waiting for things to get interesting. Thankfully, once the horror finally arrives, the movie makes up for lost time.
I give Spirit Tasting four out of five stars.
What begins as a leisurely evening of drinking and reminiscing eventually transforms into a wonderfully twisted celebration of supernatural horror, dark comedy and gloriously excessive gore. Solomon is an entertaining villain, the practical effects are impressive and the film delivers a clever ending that brings everything together nicely.
While the slow buildup occasionally tests your patience, the increasingly outrageous consequences make the journey worthwhile. For a movie made in four days with just $40,000, there’s an impressive amount of creativity and personality on display.
And if someone ever offers to grant me a wish while pouring a mysterious glass of liquor, I think I’ll stick with a Mountain Dew instead.